What Dessert Should I Serve On Christmas Eve?

Help! I'm looking for a new Christmas dessert to serve this Christmas Eve.

I'm switching up Christmas Eve dinner this year and I'm serving homemade chicken and dumplings.

Normally, I would serve appetizers on Christmas Eve with a pumpkin and a banana cream pie. But this year, I'll serve the pumpkin and banana cream pie on Christmas Day, along with the traditional turkey & ham dinner.

What dessert should I serve on Christmas Eve?