Yesterday American Idol announced that Mariah Carey would be a judge for the upcoming season of A.I.

That got me thinking ... They should fill the other judge chair with a country superstar. To me this makes total sense because the winner and runner up from last season are country artists. Not to mention how successful past country singer winners are .... example ... Carrie Underwood.

Which country star would make a good American Idol judge?

My picks are Toby Keith or Tim McGraw.