The Top 5 Most Underrated Pizza Joints in Yakima

Mr. Pizza

Pizza Pie
Getty Images

2019 Fruitvale Blvd

This place is so underrated to me that I've never even been there! It's so inconspicuous next to the convenience store on Fruitvale Blvd that I would never have noticed it if it weren't for me hitting up Google one day to search for "Yakima Pizza Restaurants". I've not really heard many things about Mr. Pizza except for one person in my entire 20 years time of living here in Yakima!

Roundtable Pizza - Yakima

1300 N 40th Ave

In my not-so-humble opinion, Roundtable Pizza has THE best pizza in Yakima. I've only had the luxury of their pizza about 3 or 4 times in my life. You would think that if I enjoy their pizza so much I would eat there constantly. I would, except the way my bank account is set up, I can't afford to eat their pizza all that often. I should really stay on the lookout for some coupons. I'm past my time on becoming a couponer; I need to jump on that! BONUS: All the pizzas on the menu are named after one of the Knights of the Roundtable (get it, the Roundtable Pizza)!

92.9 The Bull logo
Get our free mobile app

Abby's Legendary Pizza - Yakima

4804 Tieton Dr

Abby's Pizza is the very first pizza joint I ever went to when I moved to Yakima in 2002. One of our radio stations even had an American Idol Finale Viewing Party there and we gave away free tickets to come to our party. The pizza was paid for by us and for me, it was love at first bite. I've been to a few kids' birthday parties here, too. Abby's Pizza used to be very kid-friendly. I haven't been there in ages so I'll have to go check them out and see if they still are. I would love to eat some of their pizza again!

Photo by Getúlio Moraes on Unsplash

Tony's Big Cheese Pizza - Yakima

2204 W Nob Hill Blvd Suite C

Tony's Big Cheese Pizza has the best cheap pizza in town, according to me. You can't go wrong with one of their $6 pepperoni pizzas! I always ask for a big tub of their marinara sauce because I love dunking my pizza crust in it, right after I dunk it into a tub of ranch dressing!

92.9 The Bull logo
Get our free mobile app
Getty Images/Ryan McVay

Russillo's Pizza & Gelato - Yakima

32 N Front St #102

They have the biggest slices of pizza in town and their pizzas are cooked in a humongous oven. Me likey! I have always loved Russillo's pizza and their gelato is some of the best in the world (okay, slight exaggeration, but it IS really delicious)! I love the rustic way the pizza is made and baked. Hands down a treat to eat!

There you have it, the top 4 most underrated pizza joints in Yakima. Which place in town is your pick?

The Best TASTY Hometown Diners in the Yakima Valley

Try them out and see which one will become your favorite.

More From 92.9 The Bull